
In fact Dollar Tree STILL sells these and I allllmmmoooosssst grabbed 10 for the party, but I didn’t know how many kids would be coming and I wanted the kids to be able to “see” their drinks…more on that in a coming blog post….all that said…I love Dollar Tree and so Super and I headed out to peruse (what ended up being SEVERAL locations) what they had on hand to help dress up our HP2 party. I love grabbing things that I can use in the future, and if there had been CLEAR versions of the tableware I would have grabbed those, but of the colors available at the stores we hit up, we decided on purple. It was a nice accent color for our witch’s brew of a party and given myself and P, it’s highly likely we will find a use for these at a party in the future!
But I still wasn’t sold and I didn’t know why until I realized…how “unreal” these eyeballs looked…I mean who is going to have a goblet full of RED eyeballs…surely a witch would have need of different kinds and colors…duh! So five minutes before I had to leave to pick both kiddos up for school I ran to the craft studio and grabbed some sharpies…I thought, perfect, sweet and easy…I’ll color the red blue and green and this will totally work and not look like I got them at the dollar store, LOL! Only sharpie didn’t cover any of the red…and now I only had three minutes to get ready to leave for school pick up but I was in the middle of a very heated idea so I ran back down to the craft studio and grabbed my acrylic paints, a small brush and quickly tested the paint…BINGO!! Ah I could rest easy…well at least leave and get the kids without being totally distracted…I would paint the eyes blue and green, *long happy sigh*.
![]() |
| I often yell at P for diving into a project at in-opportune times… this moment taught me exactly where she gets it from!! |
I had split the eyes into two piles, blue and green, but a few eye balls in I started to feel bad about not having my own kiddos eye color represented…after all I’ve heard the story about how Super felt bad about his brown eyes when his blue eyed sister came onto the scene and they were all the talk when family came to visit. So I looked up how to make brown paint…seemed easy enough…but it did take me two tries to get it right. I ended up mixing red, yellow and blue paint, and when I say mix, I mean, MIX…it took forever to get those colors blended. Once they were blended (you couldn’t seen any of the original three colors) I let it sit for a few minutes and I suddenly had brown!! Hooray! I was so happy for my kiddos!!
I really couldn’t get over how much having a VARIETY of eye colors helps to disguise that they were printed, plastic ping pong balls from Dollar Tree!
Once all the eyes were painted (I actually didn’t keep any of them red) I noticed that the paint, upon closer inspection, looked a little sloppy…so I grabbed a black sharpie and went around each eye ball and tidied up the edges…would our HP2 guests be looking that closely? Probably not, or at least not everyone, but the ones that would get that close…well…the devil is in the details…and I like to make sure my details are on point…besides, EYE (lol) would know…and it would drive me crazy…
![]() |
| Before touching up the black on the left and after on the right. |
![]() |
| Done! All three, basic color of eyes finished and ready for use in any potion. |
![]() |
| And used in our basement photo shoot set up the next day! |





















Leave a comment